top of page
Writer's pictureMallory Shotwell

Knowledge as Power: Why We Must Talk About Systemic Issues in the Arts



The arts are often celebrated as a space of creativity, expression, and freedom. Yet, beneath this ideal lies a complex web of systemic challenges that artists face every day—issues tied to inequity, privilege, access, leadership, and sustainability. Artists are frequently led to believe their struggles are personal, isolated experiences, but the truth is far more interconnected. These challenges are systemic, rooted in structures that prioritize exclusivity over inclusion, financial precarity over sustainability, and gatekeeping over opportunity.


This series serves as the foundation for a broader exploration into the systemic barriers facing artists and arts organizations. Through data, research, and critical analysis, we aim to illuminate the shared experiences that artists encounter across their careers and provide tools to confront and navigate these challenges. By fostering awareness and knowledge, we can move toward building a more equitable and sustainable arts ecosystem—one that values the contributions of all artists and communities.


Systemic Issues: Why We Need to Talk About Them


1. Artists Are Not Alone in Their Struggles


One of the most pervasive myths in the arts is that an artist’s struggles—whether financial instability, rejection, or burnout—are purely individual. This belief isolates artists, discouraging collaboration and systemic critique.

Data Insight: More than 60% of art graduates leave the arts within five years of graduating, according to BFAMFAPhD. This statistic highlights how systemic challenges, rather than individual failures, drive artists out of their chosen field.

Implication: Writing about these issues creates a collective understanding, empowering artists to see their experiences as part of larger structural dynamics.


2. The Role of Privilege and Access


Access to opportunities in the arts—education, funding, representation—remains deeply unequal. These disparities are not accidental; they are the result of entrenched systems of privilege and gatekeeping.

Data Insight: The Helicon Collaborative’s 2017 report revealed that 80% of arts funding in the U.S. goes to large institutions led by white men, while organizations led by people of color receive only 4% of total funding.

Implication: These inequities shape who gets to make art, whose stories are told, and who benefits from artistic labor. Writing about privilege and access challenges these power structures and advocates for systemic change.


3. The Psychological Toll on Artists


Systemic barriers in the arts—such as inequitable funding, exploitative practices, and cultural myths like the “starving artist”—take a significant psychological toll on individuals. Artists face imposter syndrome, fear of rejection, and burnout at alarming rates.

Data Insight: A 2019 study by Americans for the Arts found that 56% of artists report significant mental health challenges tied to financial insecurity and lack of resources.

Scholarship Insight: In The Artist’s Way, Julia Cameron describes how external pressures and systemic inequities can create “creative blocks,” inhibiting both artistic expression and professional growth.

Implication: By addressing the psychological impacts of systemic barriers, writing can offer tools for resilience and encourage artists to prioritize mental health.


4. Lack of Transparency Perpetuates Inequity


The arts sector often operates with a lack of transparency—whether in funding allocation, gallery practices, or leadership decisions. This opacity fosters gatekeeping, exploitation, and inequity.

Example: Many artists sign contracts with galleries or organizations without fully understanding the terms, leading to financial losses or restricted opportunities. Writing that uncovers these hidden dynamics equips artists to make informed decisions and advocate for transparency.


The Power of Writing as a Tool for Change


1. Building Awareness and Advocacy


Writing about systemic issues brings these challenges to light, making the invisible visible.

Example: Articles that analyze funding inequities or predatory gallery practices provide artists with the knowledge to navigate these systems and advocate for equitable change.

Scholarship Insight: Pierre Bourdieu’s Distinction highlights how cultural hierarchies are maintained through unspoken rules and norms. Writing about these structures helps dismantle their power.


2. Connecting Individual Experiences to Larger Systems


Many artists internalize systemic failures, believing their struggles stem from personal inadequacies. Writing connects individual experiences to systemic patterns, fostering solidarity and collective action.

Scholarship Insight: Brené Brown, in Daring Greatly, argues that naming and sharing vulnerabilities is essential for breaking down shame and isolation.


3. Proposing Solutions and Reimagining Systems


Writing about systemic issues is not just about critique—it’s about envisioning alternatives. Whether exploring equitable funding models, advocating for artist residencies, or challenging gatekeeping practices, writing provides a roadmap for change.

Example: Discussions of universal basic income for artists or cooperative gallery models inspire systemic reforms that prioritize sustainability and inclusion.


Why This Series Exists


This series introduces a series of in-depth explorations into the systemic challenges artists face. Each piece will address a specific issue—whether navigating gallery contracts, identifying equitable funding opportunities, or understanding the psychological impacts of systemic inequities.


Together, these articles aim to:

• Empower artists with knowledge to navigate and challenge inequities.

• Foster a collective understanding of the barriers facing the arts sector.

• Advocate for systemic reforms that prioritize equity, inclusion, and sustainability.


The Stakes: Why This Matters


When systemic issues in the arts go unaddressed, they perpetuate cycles of inequity, exclusion, and exploitation. Artists are left isolated, undervalued, and underpaid, while institutions and gatekeepers maintain control over resources and narratives. Writing about these challenges is not just an academic exercise—it is an act of resistance and a tool for empowerment.


As artists and arts advocates, we have a responsibility to name these issues, challenge the systems that uphold them, and imagine a more equitable future. With knowledge and awareness, we can grow—not just as individuals, but as a community capable of driving meaningful change.


Works Cited

• BFAMFAPhD. Artists Report Back: A National Study on the Lives of Arts Graduates and Working Artists. 2018.

• Bourdieu, Pierre. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste. Harvard University Press, 1984.

• Brown, Brené. Daring Greatly. Gotham Books, 2012.

• Cameron, Julia. The Artist’s Way. TarcherPerigee, 1992.

• Helicon Collaborative. Not Just Money: Equity Issues in Cultural Philanthropy. 2017.

• National Endowment for the Arts. Artists and Other Cultural Workers: A Statistical Portrait. 2019.

Comments


bottom of page