How It Works, Where to Find It, and Why It Matters
Private philanthropy is a vital source of funding for the arts, filling gaps left by government funding and offering flexible, targeted support for artists and organizations. Donations from individuals, foundations, and corporations have shaped cultural landscapes for centuries, from the Medici family’s Renaissance patronage to today’s multi-million-dollar foundations. While private philanthropy offers immense opportunities, it also comes with challenges, including equity concerns, donor influence, and reliance on personal networks.
This second installment of our funding series explores the role of private philanthropy in the arts, examining its financial scope, historical roots, major programs, and its value in the arts ecosystem.
Understanding Private Philanthropy in the Arts
What Is Private Philanthropy?
Private philanthropy refers to financial support for the arts provided by:
1. Individual Donors: Private citizens, ranging from small-scale supporters to high-net-worth individuals.
2. Foundations: Charitable organizations that distribute grants to artists and arts organizations. Examples include family foundations, like the Mellon Foundation, and corporate foundations, such as the Ford Foundation.
3. Corporations: Businesses that fund the arts through sponsorships, corporate foundations, or matching gift programs.
Historical Context
The tradition of private philanthropy in the arts dates back centuries:
• Renaissance Italy: The Medici family supported artists like Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci, funding some of the most iconic works in Western art.
• 19th and 20th Centuries: Industrialists like Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller established philanthropic foundations that transformed cultural landscapes. For instance, the Rockefeller Foundation funded major institutions like the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) and the American Ballet Theatre.
In the U.S., philanthropic giving to the arts expanded in the 20th century alongside tax incentives for charitable donations, such as the creation of the modern income tax deduction in 1917.
Scope and Scale of Private Philanthropy
United States
• Annual Giving: Americans donated $20.07 billion to arts, culture, and humanities organizations in 2022, according to Giving USA. This represented 4% of total charitable giving in the U.S.
• Key Foundations:
• Mellon Foundation: One of the largest arts funders, investing over $500 million annually in arts and humanities initiatives.
• Ford Foundation: Focuses on cultural equity, supporting artists and organizations addressing social justice issues.
• Getty Foundation: Funds conservation, research, and arts education globally.
Canada
• Annual Giving: Private philanthropic giving to the arts in Canada reached an estimated $1.2 billion CAD in 2021, according to Imagine Canada.
• Key Foundations:
• Azrieli Foundation: Supports arts education and music programs.
• Metcalf Foundation: Funds professional development for artists and cultural leaders.
• Banff Centre for Arts and Creativity: Receives significant private donations to support artist residencies and training.
United Kingdom
• Annual Giving: In 2021, private philanthropy contributed £660 million to arts and culture, according to Arts Council England.
• Key Foundations:
• Paul Hamlyn Foundation: Provides grants for artists, arts education, and community engagement.
• Clore Duffield Foundation: Focuses on cultural leadership and creative learning.
• Art Fund: Helps museums and galleries acquire significant works of art.
How Private Philanthropy is Distributed
1. Individual Giving
Individual donors contribute to the arts through direct gifts, bequests, or membership programs. High-net-worth individuals often establish family foundations to formalize their giving. For example, the Bloomberg Philanthropies Arts Program supports public art projects and arts education initiatives worldwide.
2. Foundations
Foundations provide grants to individual artists and arts organizations through structured programs. Many foundations target specific disciplines or causes, such as the preservation of cultural heritage, promoting equity, or supporting emerging artists.
Key Examples:
• The Mellon Foundation funds initiatives like the Art Museum Futures Fund, which supports small and mid-sized museums post-pandemic.
• The Ford Foundation’s Art for Justice Fund allocated $125 million to projects addressing mass incarceration through art.
3. Corporate Philanthropy
Corporations engage in arts funding through sponsorships, matching employee donations, or creating corporate foundations. These contributions often align with marketing goals, such as brand visibility or corporate social responsibility (CSR).
Key Examples:
• BMW’s Art Journey Program funds international travel and research for contemporary artists.
• Google Arts & Culture supports digital initiatives, such as virtual museum tours and artist residencies.
Value of Private Philanthropy in the Arts
1. Flexibility and Innovation
Private funders can support experimental and high-risk projects that may not meet the criteria for government funding. For instance, the Getty Foundation’s Pacific Standard Time initiative encouraged Southern California museums to collaborate on ambitious exhibitions exploring Latinx art.
2. Targeted Support
Many private donors focus on specific causes, such as arts education or diversity initiatives, allowing them to address systemic gaps. For example, the Paul Hamlyn Foundation’s arts program prioritizes access and inclusion for underserved communities.
3. Global Reach
Unlike government funding, which is often geographically restricted, private philanthropy frequently operates across borders. Organizations like the Aga Khan Foundation fund cultural preservation and education initiatives worldwide.
4. Capacity Building
Foundations often invest in long-term capacity building for arts organizations, providing funding for leadership training, infrastructure, or endowments. The Clore Leadership Programme, funded by the Clore Duffield Foundation, is a leading example of this approach in the U.K.
Challenges and Critiques of Private Philanthropy
1. Equity Concerns
Private philanthropy often skews toward established institutions rather than grassroots or emerging artists. A 2017 report by SMU DataArts found that only 2% of arts philanthropy in the U.S. went to organizations led by people of color.
2. Donor Influence
Donors may impose restrictions on how funds are used or influence the direction of artistic work. For example, corporate sponsors might prioritize projects that align with their brand image.
3. Reliance on Wealth
Private philanthropy relies on the wealth of individuals and corporations, making it vulnerable to economic fluctuations. During the 2008 financial crisis, arts donations dropped significantly, leaving many organizations struggling to survive.
4. Regional Disparities
In countries like the U.S. and U.K., philanthropic giving is often concentrated in urban centers, leaving rural or underserved areas with limited access to private funding.
How to Access Private Philanthropy
1. Research Foundations and Programs
Use online databases and resources to identify funders aligned with your work.
• Foundation Directory Online: A comprehensive database of U.S. grantmakers.
• CanadaHelps: Lists Canadian foundations and funding opportunities.
• 360Giving: Tracks U.K. philanthropic grants.
2. Cultivate Relationships
Building relationships with donors and foundations is critical. Attend networking events, engage with arts advocacy groups, and connect with funders through shared projects or causes.
3. Tailor Applications
Each foundation has specific priorities and guidelines. Tailor your grant proposals to reflect the funder’s mission and demonstrate alignment with their goals.
4. Collaborate
Partnerships with other organizations can increase your visibility and eligibility for foundation funding. Collaborative projects often attract philanthropic interest.
Examples of Impactful Private Philanthropy
1. The Mellon Foundation’s Monument Lab: A $4 million initiative to reimagine public monuments and reflect more inclusive histories.
2. Art Fund’s Acquisition Program: Helped the British Museum acquire significant works, such as the 2020 purchase of 17th-century African bronzes.
3. Bloomberg Philanthropies’ Public Art Challenge: Allocated $43 million to create public art projects in 26 cities worldwide.
Conclusion: The Role of Private Philanthropy in the Arts Ecosystem
Private philanthropy is a cornerstone of the arts ecosystem, complementing government funding by offering flexibility, innovation, and targeted impact. However, its reliance on wealth and influence raises critical questions about equity and accessibility. By understanding its opportunities and limitations, artists and organizations can better leverage this vital funding source to sustain and expand their work.
Next in this series, we’ll explore earned income, examining how artists and organizations can generate sustainable revenue through ticket sales, merchandise, and other commercial activities.
Works Cited
• Giving USA 2022: Annual Report on Philanthropy.
• Mellon Foundation. Annual Report 2021. Retrieved from mellon.org.
• Arts Council England. Private Investment in Culture Report. Retrieved from artscouncil.org.uk.
• Ford Foundation. Art for Justice Fund. Retrieved from fordfoundation.org.
• Imagine Canada. Sector Monitor Report 2021.
Comments